
from prd-debate21
Run a multi-agent, cross-model adversarial debate to produce a high-quality product requirements document (PRD) and decision log.
This skill orchestrates a structured, multi-agent debate to produce product documentation (PRD), summaries, and a decision log. It assigns three roles—Host (orchestrator), Proposer (generates proposals via Codex/GPT-5.4), and Reviewer (Claude-based critic)—and runs iterative proposal/critique rounds, framework design, optional codebase research, and final synthesis into a PRD. The emphasis is always product-level decisions (what and why), not technical implementation.
Use this skill when you need to: create or refine a PRD, make complex product or strategy decisions requiring multiple perspectives, compare competing product options, or run a structured decision process that benefits from adversarial review. Not suitable for simple single-shot docs, code review, or low-level technical architecture design.
Designed for environments with Codex CLI and Claude Code support; expects a proposer model (GPT-5.4/Codex) and a Claude reviewer.
A structured multi-agent debate skill for producing high-quality PRDs via adversarial rounds between a Proposer (GPT-5.4 via Codex CLI) and Reviewer (Claude). No bundled scripts to test. SKILL.md is very detailed with clear phases, state management, and constraints. Uses codex exec --full-auto which auto-executes without confirmation, and variable interpolation in bash command templates presents shell injection risk.
Well-crafted skill with thoughtful structure. Shell injection risk from unquoted variable interpolation in bash command templates. The --full-auto flag on codex exec bypasses human confirmation. Skill is entirely in Chinese which limits global usability.