Paper Review Pipeline

What it does

Run a two-view review for ML conference submissions: (A) a section-by-section critique with concrete edits and (B) a prioritized P0/P1/P2 issue list with verification notes. It also supports drafting professional rebuttals and revision plans while enforcing guardrails such as no hallucinated citations and preservation of LaTeX semantics.

When to use it

Use this skill for pre-submission QA (ICML/ICLR/NeurIPS/AAAI) when a draft is mostly complete and you want clarity, citation checks, or a camera-ready polish. Also use after receiving reviewer comments to classify feedback and draft point-by-point rebuttals. Do NOT use for initial drafting or inventing new experiments.

What's included

• Scripts: references/ (detailed protocols and checklists present in the repo)
• References: parity-matrix, report-template, module checklists and citation integrity guides (has_references=true)
• Instructions: triage, section-by-section review, P0/P1/P2 consolidation, optional full-parallel workflow, and rebuttal workflow. The skill includes explicit templates and verification steps for citations and LaTeX-safe edits.

Compatible agents

Best suited for agents with strong text-editing and research tooling (Claude Code, Codex, Copilot-style agents). The workflow expects access to file-reading and document inspection tools.