
from reaper8
Provide structured critique of investigation results via human feedback, Codex consultation, or agent self-review to uncover gaps, alternative hypotheses, and n
Critique adds a dedicated review layer to a research investigation pipeline. It accepts human feedback, consults an external AI (Codex) as a devil's advocate or inspiration, or performs an automated self-review. The skill classifies feedback, logs consultation results, and creates actionable hypotheses or workflow signals that can trigger further investigation cycles.
Use Critique after an investigation run has produced findings and you want: to refine conclusions with human input, obtain an independent AI second opinion, or have the agent check its own work for weak claims and untested assumptions. It's appropriate when you need targeted follow-up (deepen/explore), formal re-framing (scope), or purely editorial improvements (rewrite).
Designed for multi-agent research pipelines and MCP-capable hosts. The repo reports compatibility with Codex CLI, Cursor, Claude Code, Gemini CLI and other research tools (MCP tooling) for Codex consultations.
The reaper-critique skill provides structured critique of investigation results through three modes: human feedback, Codex (external AI) consultation, and self-review. No bundled scripts — purely instruction-based. SKILL.md is well-documented with clear mode separation, feedback categorization, and quality criteria. Tightly coupled to the reaper workspace structure, limiting reuse outside that ecosystem.
No security concerns. Pure instruction skill with no executable scripts. Niche utility as it's specific to the reaper investigation framework.